Reservation
+1 920-743-5593
Visit Us
1541 Egg Harbor Rd, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, United States
Hello dear
Welcome To Nightingale Supper Club
Located in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin, Nightingale Supper Club invites diners to experience a classic American dining atmosphere enriched with nautical decor. This beloved supper club is renowned for its impressive menu, featuring mouthwatering dishes such as bacon-wrapped scallops, succulent prime rib, and delectable lobster tails. Patrons rave about the attentive service, which complements the inviting ambiance, making it perfect for special occasions or a casual night out. With a diverse selection of options for children and nightly specials, including grilled salmon and beef tenderloin, Nightingale Supper Club truly caters to all tastes, delivering memorable culinary experiences night after night.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Bacon Wrapped Scallops
Fettuccini Alfredo
Surf & Turf
Lobster Tail
About
Nightingale Supper Club
Welcome to the enchanting world of the Nightingale Supper Club, a culinary haven tucked away in scenic Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin. Located at 1541 Egg Harbor Rd, this charming establishment embraces the timeless tradition of American supper clubs, melding warm hospitality with a menu that dazzles the senses.
As you step inside, you’re greeted by a nautical-themed decor that evokes a sense of nostalgia, complete with exquisite rope chandeliers. The atmosphere is vibrant yet cozy, perfect for intimate dinners or lively gatherings with friends and family. It's no surprise that the Nightingale Supper Club is a beloved choice for both locals and visitors alike.
The menu is a delightful mix of classic and contemporary dishes, featuring starters like Bacon Wrapped Scallops served with a luscious maple bourbon sauce, and House Smoked Local Whitefish Cakes accompanied by a zesty roasted red pepper remoulade. Each dish is a testament to the culinary craftsmanship at Nightingale, aimed at satisfying even the most discerning palates.
Fans of burgers won’t want to miss the Half Pound Burger, made with house-ground Black Angus, or the indulgent Prime Rib Sandwich that promises an explosion of flavor with every bite. Almost every review praises the Prime Rib, often described as the best they’ve ever had—a sentiment echoed by many who’ve celebrated special occasions at this remarkable establishment.
For those seeking lighter fare, the Caesar Salad and the D.C. Cherry Salad present fresh and vibrant options, ensuring that every meal can be tailored to your preferences. And do not overlook the selection of soups—the Creamy Crab & Asparagus soup has garnered rave reviews for its rich flavor, proving to be the perfect starter on cooler evenings.
However, what truly sets Nightingale apart is the dedication to excellent service. Patrons share stories of exceptional hospitality from the staff, who make every visit feel uniquely special. The commitment to creating memorable dining experiences is evident, from the moment you walk in until your last bite of a decadent dessert, like the rich chocolate cake, ideal for sharing.
The Nightingale Supper Club is more than just a restaurant; it’s a celebration of good food, good company, and unforgettable memories. Whether you’re craving a comforting meal, a lively atmosphere, or a taste of nostalgia, Nightingale promises to deliver on all fronts. So gather your friends, make a reservation, and prepare for an evening filled with culinary delights and heartwarming service—you won’t leave disappointed!
To learn more or to make a reservation, call +1 920-743-5593. Dive into a dining experience that celebrates the best of what a supper club can offer—only at Nightingale!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I am 30 weeks pregnant and have been cravings for barbecue ribs I am so glad that my husband took me here for my birthday dinner He ordered steaks he shared it to me and it was fantastic, I ordered barbecue baby back ribs and it was amazing! I had a crab asparagus soup for my side it was superb! all the food we ordered from here fullfilled my pregnancy cravings. 4 thumbs up from me and hubby definitely recommend this place to our friends. We are from Madison by the way ”
“ This is an old school supper club, decorated in classic nautical style, complete with rope chandeliers. It’s popular and gets busy on weekends, so when we wanted to do a girls night but couldn’t get reservations until late, we decided to order prime rib for carryout, open a bottle of wine and have a girls night in. Such a good decision, we had so much fun! They have such a big selection of sides and toppings for your steak, the employee who took our order was a real pro, everything was packaged nicely and made a great dining experience. Orders were correct, we just felt steaks were just cooked a little less than we expected, medium well was still quite pink, but since we were home we cooked them a little more ourselves. ”
“ What a great experience at Nightingale! This place had a great atmosphere and absolutely fantastic Prime Rib ! Meghan our server and John the owner were awesome too along with the bartenders! Our friends 50th birthday was that day and the Nightingale staff treated us great! All of our food was fantastic! We'll be back when in Door County for sure! ”
“ One of the best supper club experiences I have had. Food was amazing, drinks were perfect and other patrons were so friendly. Get there early or make reservations ahead of time. Place really fills up fast! ”
“ We had reservations for 730. Upon arrival, we were given a pager while they got our table ready. We took a seat at the bar and I ordered a Cherry Cosmo. We barely got our drinks and our pager went off. We were seated in the beautiful dining room and our server greeted us almost immediately. She made a recommendation of the prime rib but did tell us that they were featuring their fish fry. My husband ordered the 16 ounce prime which was absolutely delicious! One of the best primes my husband has ever had!!! I ordered the pan fried walleye which I thought was ok. The breading tasted very floury, and it was on the soggy side. Could have been fried a minute or two longer. We ordered the chocolate cake for dessert which was very rich and delicious and perfect for sharing. Service was great from the moment we walked in until we left. ”
“ This place was STUPID good, says my wife. The food was incredible. For about 140 weeks got 4 cocktails, steak, pasta, a starter, steak bites for my daughter, soups and salads. We didn’t have one bad thing. A meal like this in the city would be 300-400. Highly recommended. Also, other than the amazing steaks, the fettuccini Alfredo (while also being the only pasta on the menu) was again, stupid good. Go eat at this place NOW. ”
“ Who doesn't love a WI Supper Club? Atmosphere- This one did not disappoint. A large space with an entire bar room holding ample seating at and around the bar. The bar has an extensive and varied menu of options from WI staples to an espresso martini. Food- Delicious ribeyes cooked medium rare with a nice charred outside. The BEST ranch on a crisp salad. The crab asparagus soup was different, but a good different! The only negative- canned soda. No tap beers- only bottle or can. ”
“ Can I give 6 stars!?!?!? Love this place! Went once in 2017 and again last night. Both times the food and service were amazing. Live over 4 hours away and would drive the distance just to eat here again. Hopefully won't be another 8 years before I return. ”